SEC Nominee Johnson Backs Full Tokenized-Stock Rules

SUMMARY
- Johnson backs notice-and-comment rules over the exemption
- Direct venue buyers lack a clear best-execution owner
- Sixty-plus companies object to third-party tokenization
- Tokenizer insolvency remains an unanswered holder risk
She made that case at her November 19 Senate Banking Committee hearing, CoinDesk reported, arguing that rules shaped by public comment hold up better than an exemption issued without it.
Johnson and Levine Split on Timing, Not Destination
Johnson said she would welcome a formal rulemaking with a public comment period, particularly because the objections are coming from market participants and SEC registrants. Independent regulators, she argued, are expected to go through notice and comment.
Steven Levine, the Republican nominee at the same hearing, called the exemption narrow and time-limited. He pointed to exchange-traded funds, which began under exemptive orders before formal rules followed. Chairman Paul Atkins made a similar point when the order was issued, presenting it in his accompanying statement as a bridge toward durable rulemaking. The disagreement is about sequence: whether venues should operate under conditional relief while permanent rules are written, or wait for them.
Johnson, a former CFTC commissioner who now teaches at George Washington University Law School, would be the commission’s only Democrat if confirmed. If Levine is also confirmed, the SEC would have four members, three of them Republicans. Her prepared testimony focused on governance, conflicts of interest and the segregation of customer assets in digital-asset markets. The Banking Committee still has to vote on whether to send both nominations to the full Senate.
What the September Order Already Permits
The SEC’s September 17 Innovation Exemption lets qualifying Tokenized Securities Venues trade tokenized versions of National Market System stocks, broadly US-listed shares, without registering as exchanges. Trading runs through permissioned automated market makers: liquidity pools where approved participants trade under access standards each venue sets.
Liquidity providers that supply those pools with their own capital also receive relief from the “dealer” definition. In practice, firms can make markets in tokenized shares without registering as dealers, a status that would otherwise bring capital and conduct requirements.
The relief has limits. Venues face caps on how many symbols they list and how much volume they trade. They must verify that each token carries the same rights as the conventional share and run their smart contracts publicly on a permissionless blockchain. A token must stop trading whenever its underlying stock is halted on its primary exchange, and venues must disclose their operations along with their affiliates’ trading. The exemption lapses five years after publication, and federal antifraud and anti-manipulation rules still apply. Coindoo covered these conditions when the route first opened.
Nearly every one of those conditions governs the venue. What happens to the person holding the token after the trade is where the senators’ objections begin.
Four Points Where a Tokenized Share Can Fail Its Holder
Senators Angela Alsobrooks, Catherine Cortez Masto, Mark Warner and Ruben Gallego wrote to Atkins objecting that the order took effect immediately, with public comment invited only afterward. They want changes made through rulemaking, stated that “a tokenized security is a security,” and asked the SEC to answer 13 questions within 30 days. Followed from purchase to exit, those questions expose four gaps.
Buying without a broker
Retail investors can buy tokenized shares directly from a venue, with no broker-dealer in between. A broker normally owes customers best execution, a duty to seek the most favorable available terms for each order. The senators ask who owes that duty when no broker is involved, and whether advertising rules and SIPC coverage, which protects customers when a brokerage fails, apply at all. They also note that the venues are not bound by Regulation NMS, so they need not display the best available price or report trades in real time.
Holding a token someone else created
A tokenized share can come from the listed company itself or from an unaffiliated third party that holds the underlying stock and issues tokens against it. In the second case, the token depends on the tokenizer’s custody and record-keeping as much as on the company. The venue must confirm equivalent rights, but the senators ask how the SEC checks that tokens are fully backed and how the underlying shares must be held. The official shareholder register and the onchain token have to be read together, as Coindoo’s look at tokenized-share records shows.
Moving the token off the venue
Venue access and token movement are controlled separately. According to the letter, the order sets no token-level transfer restrictions, so a token bought by a verified customer can move to an unverified or offshore wallet. Venues must be US persons subject to sanctions rules, but the senators say the order sets no identity-verification standard, requires no anti-money-laundering program and leaves venues outside the Bank Secrecy Act. They ask whether the SEC can trace, freeze or recover tokens once they leave.
Exiting if the tokenizer fails
The hardest question in the letter is what a holder legally owns. If a third-party tokenizer becomes insolvent, the order does not say whether the token holder can claim the underlying shares directly or holds only a claim against the failed company. With SIPC coverage also unclear, there is no obvious backstop.
Documents to request before buying
Token terms
Names the token’s issuer and shows whether the listed company is a party to it.
Custody agreement
Identifies who holds the underlying shares and whether they sit apart from the tokenizer’s own assets.
Venue disclosures
Sets out access standards, affiliate trading and the AML rules the venue says it follows.
Redemption terms
States whether the token can be exchanged for the share itself, by whom and at what cost.
Why Listed Companies Are Objecting
The order gives issuers one defense against unwanted tokenization. Before a venue lists a stock tokenized by an unaffiliated party, it must notify the company in writing and give it a chance to object. According to the senators, that window closes 30 days after the notice, and it is unclear whether a company can lodge a standing objection, object later or withdraw consent it has already given.
More than sixty public companies have objected so far, the letter says, and CoinDesk has reported objections from Microsoft, Alphabet and Goldman Sachs. The senators argue the opt-out design burdens smaller companies that cannot monitor every tokenization attempt. They ask whether one objection should apply across all venues, whether issuers should have to give affirmative consent instead, and whether the SEC will keep a central public record of venue filings.
For investors, the outcome shapes which stocks reach a venue at all. Under an opt-out model, availability depends on which companies notice and object in time. Under a consent model, third parties could tokenize only the stocks whose issuers agree.
Fed Minutes Signal More Hikes – Why Bitcoin Should Care
What a Permanent Rule Would Have to Settle
A formal rule would put these gaps through the SEC’s notice-and-comment process, in which a published proposal draws public feedback and can change before adoption. Atkins has said the agency intends to take that step after testing the exemption, and Johnson wants it sooner. Neither has given a date.
Any proposal would need to assign the duties the order leaves open: best execution and SIPC status for direct customers, a minimum identity and anti-money-laundering standard, controls on where tokens can move, the treatment of holders when a tokenizer fails, and whether issuers opt in or opt out. Each answer puts costs on someone, whether wallet providers, venues, liquidity firms or listed companies, and a comment period is where those trade-offs get argued in public.
The nearer markers are the SEC’s response to the senators’ 13 questions, the Banking Committee’s vote on the two nominees and any amendment to the September order. Until a rule assigns these duties, the answers to the four gaps above are set by each product’s own terms.
This story was originally published by Coindoo. Read the original article.





