Ripple Bets on Rules Over CLARITY: Where That Falls Short

Ripple Bets on Rules Over CLARITY: Where That Falls Short

Key Takeaways

  • SEC proposal could ease token fundraising rules
  • CFTC plan covers leveraged retail crypto trades
  • Spot-market oversight still needs an act of Congress
  • Customer bankruptcy protections require statutory change

Speaking at The Hill and The Block’s Capitol Crypto Forum on November 19, Chief Legal Officer Stuart Alderoty said the focus of crypto policy will move to the SEC and CFTC, and that agency action is enough for the next two years, according to The Block’s report.

Why Ripple Is Betting on Regulators, Not Congress

Alderoty’s case rests on durability. “This administration is doing the hard work of rulemaking, and that is durable,” he said, contrasting the current approach with the SEC under Gary Gensler. In his view, rules built through public comment would be hard for a future administration to reverse.

Ripple has reason to care about that. The company spent more than four years fighting an SEC enforcement case filed in December 2020, so its legal chief has seen firsthand how the agency’s stance on crypto can shift with its leadership.

He sees the legislative route as narrower. The Block reports that Senator Elizabeth Warren, one of the industry’s most prominent critics, is expected to lead the Senate Banking Committee. Alderoty said he doesn’t believe she will set crypto policy and expects her to concentrate on oversight hearings. He also doesn’t expect a version of CLARITY to be reintroduced in the next Congress, citing a crowded calendar and the 2028 presidential race, though he said parts of it could be attached to tax or other bills.

The bill has already stalled once this session: a September 15 procedural vote failed to advance it, as Coindoo reported. Any bill still pending when the current Congress ends on January 3, 2027, has to be reintroduced and start again. That is the step Alderoty doesn’t expect.

His claim that rules are enough can be tested against the two proposals regulators have already published. Each helps a different part of the market, and each stops at a different point.

For Token Issuers, the SEC Offers a New Fundraising Path

The SEC’s Regulation Crypto Assets proposal, issued August 18, would create two exemptions from Securities Act registration for certain offerings involving crypto assets: one for up to $5 million over four years, and another for up to $75 million in each 12-month period. Issuers would provide principles-based disclosures instead of a full registration statement, and the securities laws’ anti-fraud and anti-manipulation provisions would still apply.

Today, a project selling tokens as part of an investment contract must register the offering or fit into general-purpose exemptions such as Regulation D or Regulation A, none of which were written with tokens in mind. The proposal would give smaller and mid-sized raises a route built for them.

The proposal’s second element deals with what happens after the sale. It includes a conditional safe harbor from the term “investment contract,” the part of the definition of a security at the centre of most crypto enforcement cases. An arrangement that meets the conditions would fall outside that definition, which affects whether the token can later trade as something other than a security. The SEC’s summary page does not set out those conditions, so the number of projects that could rely on it will only be clear from the full text.

The proposal does not set registration rules for the platforms where tokens trade. Its comment period closed on October 20, and it stays a proposal until the Commission votes on a final version.

For Trading Platforms, the CFTC’s Reach Starts With Leverage

The CFTC’s October 13 Federal Register notice outlines two linked proposals. Regulation CTX would identify which crypto transactions the agency believes fall under Section 2(c)(2)(D) of the Commodity Exchange Act. Regulation CAM would adapt the requirements for exchange-traded futures to those transactions.

Section 2(c)(2)(D), added by the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010, covers commodity transactions offered to retail customers (anyone who isn’t an eligible contract participant or eligible commercial entity) on a leveraged, margined or financed basis. The financing can come from the seller, the counterparty or someone acting with either of them, so a platform that only arranges credit can still be covered. The law treats these transactions as if they were futures.

Take a platform that lets retail customers buy bitcoin with borrowed money. Unless the coins are actually delivered to the customer within 28 days, which is the statute’s main exception, the platform generally cannot offer that product unless the trades are conducted on or subject to the rules of a designated contract market. Calling it a spot purchase does not change that. The CFTC withdrew its 2020 guidance on what counts as actual delivery in December 2025, which leaves Regulation CTX’s list of covered transactions doing much of the work.

The two agencies’ proposals meet at one point. Securities are excluded from Section 2(c)(2)(D), so the SEC’s line on what counts as an investment contract helps decide which tokens the CFTC framework can reach at all.

An ordinary, unleveraged purchase sits outside this framework. For those trades, the CFTC can pursue fraud and manipulation, but it does not register or supervise the platforms. CLARITY would have changed that. A Congressional Research Service analysis of the September draft describes exclusive CFTC jurisdiction over cash and spot sales of digital commodities, with mandatory registration for the exchanges, brokers and dealers operating in those markets.

The CFTC notice is an advance notice, and comments are due December 14. A proposed rule, and then a final one, would still have to follow. Coindoo covered the plan’s earlier White House review.

Terms used in this article

ANPRM
An advance notice of proposed rulemaking. It asks for public input before an agency drafts rule text and creates no binding requirements. Designated contract market
An exchange registered with the CFTC to list futures, subject to its rules on trading, surveillance and customer protection. Eligible contract participant
Mainly institutions and wealthy investors. For individuals, generally more than $10 million invested on a discretionary basis, or $5 million when hedging risk. Stockbroker liquidation
A Bankruptcy Code process in which customers share a pool of customer property ahead of a failed broker’s general creditors.

For Customers, Bankruptcy Treatment Still Needs Congress

The same CRS analysis points to a change no agency rule can make. The draft would amend the Bankruptcy Code’s stockbroker-liquidation provisions so that holders of digital assets are treated as customers, their assets are counted as customer property, and intermediaries generally cannot commingle customer assets with their own funds.

Today, a crypto customer’s position in an exchange or lender bankruptcy can turn on the platform’s terms of service. In the Celsius case, a federal bankruptcy judge ruled in January 2023 that assets in the lender’s Earn program belonged to the bankruptcy estate rather than to the customers who deposited them, leaving those customers as unsecured creditors.

Regulators can impose custody and segregation requirements on the firms they supervise. They cannot change how a bankruptcy court classifies customer assets once a firm fails. That requires an amendment to the statute.

SEC Nominee Johnson Backs Full Tokenized-Stock Rules

Are Agency Rules Durable? The SEC Chair Has Doubts

Alderoty’s durability argument has a prominent skeptic: the head of one of the two agencies he is counting on. In his August statement supporting Regulation Crypto Assets, SEC Chairman Paul Atkins called legislation indispensable to lasting rules, saying it guards the SEC’s work from being “unwound by a future rogue regulator,” and pledged continued support for CLARITY.

Two separate risks sit behind that concern. The first is political. A final rule can be repealed or rewritten through the same notice-and-comment process that created it. That takes time and a supporting record, which is Alderoty’s point, but it is not out of reach. Guidance is easier to drop than a rule, yet the CFTC’s withdrawal of its own 2020 actual-delivery guidance shows how an agency’s reading of the same provision can change under new leadership.

The second risk is judicial. In Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, the Supreme Court held in 2024 that courts must decide for themselves whether an agency has acted within its statutory authority, rather than defer to the agency’s reading of an ambiguous statute. The SEC’s safe harbor is the clearest test case. “Investment contract” is a statutory term the Supreme Court has interpreted since its 1946 Howey decision, so anyone challenging the rule could ask a court whether the SEC’s line matches the statute, and the court would answer that question without deferring to the agency.

Put together, the agency route offers the most to token issuers, a defined but narrow path to platforms offering leveraged trades, and the least to customers worried about what happens if a platform fails. Alderoty says that is enough for the next two years. Atkins, whose agency wrote one of the two proposals, is still asking Congress for the rest.

This story was originally published by Coindoo. Read the original article.

More Altcoins News