ARK Cancels Two Crypto Index ETFs Before Launch

ARK Cancels Two Crypto Index ETFs Before Launch

Key Takeaways

  • ARK withdrew two CoinDesk 20 ETF filings
  • Neither fund became effective or sold shares
  • Ex-Bitcoin design required shorting Bitcoin futures
  • Both designs depended on ICE CoinDesk 20 futures

In letters dated November 20, ARK asked the SEC to consent to withdrawing the ARK CoinDesk 20 ex-Bitcoin Crypto ETF and its standard counterpart, the ARK CoinDesk 20 Crypto ETF. Both registrations date from January 23. The letters say only that ARK does not intend to proceed.

Two Funds, One Futures Contract

Both products were built around the CoinDesk 20, an index of the twenty largest crypto assets by market value, excluding stablecoins and memecoins. Its factsheet sets a 30% cap on the largest member and a 20% cap on every other one, applied when the index rebalances each quarter. Bitcoin is the asset pressing against the top ceiling.

Neither fund would have held coins. Each was registered as a commodity pool, with shares to list on NYSE Arca. The standard fund’s registration describes long positions in CoinDesk 20 Index futures traded on ICE Futures U.S., with the remaining assets held in cash and Treasury securities to cover margin. Investors would have owned shares in a futures vehicle, one step further from the coins than the products in our guide to what an exchange-traded crypto product actually holds.

The ex-Bitcoin fund was meant to track the same index with its Bitcoin-related members removed, which the filing defines as both bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash. ARK planned to get there by subtraction: hold the full index through ICE futures, then sell CME Bitcoin futures to cancel the Bitcoin slice. The ex-Bitcoin registration was still a draft in key places, with the ticker, the sponsor fee and the share of assets committed to futures all left blank.

Leaving Out Bitcoin Meant Shorting It

Subtraction comes at a cost in size. With Bitcoin near its cap, each dollar of index futures carries only about 70 cents of exposure to the other members. A fund aiming to put its full value into the ex-Bitcoin basket would need a long position bigger than its own assets, plus a short large enough to neutralise the Bitcoin inside that bigger long.

Long CoinDesk 20 futures

$143

Holds about $43 of Bitcoin and $100 of everything else

Short CME Bitcoin futures

$43

Cancels the Bitcoin slice of the long position

What the fund keeps

$100

Exposure to the rest of the index, carried by $186 of futures

Illustration per $100 of fund assets, assuming a 30% Bitcoin weight and full investment. It ignores Bitcoin Cash, fees, financing and differences between the two contracts.

Because ARK left the exposure target blank, the real sizing is unknown. Its risk disclosures did warn that the trust’s operations would be “characterized by a high degree of leverage,” which fits a design carrying more futures than cash.

Paired with a long position, the short works as a neutraliser and carries no view on where Bitcoin is heading. It’s the same pairing logic behind the futures hedges that sit beside some institutional Bitcoin ETF positions.

A Hedge That Would Need Constant Resizing

The positions above would not stay put. As the rest of the index rises or falls, the fund’s assets move with it, so the long leg has to be resized to keep daily exposure on target. The short then has to follow, because it is sized against the Bitcoin inside the long. Each quarterly rebalance pulls Bitcoin’s weight back toward the cap and shifts the short again. ARK’s filing said it would “periodically adjust” its futures for these changes.

Expiring contracts would also need replacing with later-dated ones, a process known as rolling. When later contracts trade above expiring ones, rolling a long position costs money, while a short gains from the same gap. The fund’s two legs would therefore have felt roll effects in opposite directions.

Bitcoin Cash added its own mismatch. The fund intended to strip it out alongside bitcoin, yet the hedge relied on CME Bitcoin futures, and the filing conceded the two would not move in perfect step.

Cash management was the final pressure point. A Bitcoin rally would produce mark-to-market losses on the short, drawing extra margin from the Treasury holdings even while the long leg gained. And the index futures at the centre of both designs were, in ARK’s own words, “new instruments without a significant trading history.”

Bitcoin Core Patches Stall Bug Found by an AI Scan

What the Withdrawal Does and Doesn’t Show

Because ARK pulled both funds, the Bitcoin hedge cannot be singled out as the reason. What the two designs shared was the ICE CoinDesk 20 futures contract and the commodity-pool structure built around it. That overlap is a fact about the products, and ARK has not linked it to its decision.

The futures route stood out when the funds were filed. Four months earlier, the SEC had approved generic listing standards allowing exchanges to list products that hold spot commodities, including digital assets, without a separate rule change for each one, provided they meet set criteria. ARK’s January designs used futures instead, and neither the registrations nor the withdrawal letters discuss that choice.

The withdrawal is not a test of investor appetite either. With no shares ever sold, there are no flows, redemptions or trading volumes to read. ARK’s existing crypto lineup is unaffected: ARKB, the spot Bitcoin ETF it offers with 21Shares, has traded since January 2024.


This story was originally published by Coindoo. Read the original article.

More Markets News